Brighton Beach Memoirs Broadway Reviews
Monday, October 26th, 2009What Critics Thought Of Brighton Beach

BROADWAY MAGAZINE - Last night, the new Broadway revival of Neil Simon’s Brighton Beach Memoirs opened. This morning, Broadway Opening Night critics have begun to publish their reviews of the production. An examination of 12 opening night reviews yields some insight into the production. Did the critics like director David Cromer’s production of Neil Simon’s beloved comedy? In a word, “yes.” Collectively, reviewers were positive about this production in nearly every facet. Most reviewers noted the strong cast (particularly newcomer Noah Robbins), reviewers also noted that Cromer’s direction preserves the humor, but emphasizes the other dimensions of the story as well. Though multiple critics felt that Brighton Beach Memoirs as written is not canonical, this production feels effective and fresh, even given its sentimental qualities.
Three Key Take Aways From Opening Night Reviews of Brighton Beach Memoirs
- Noah Robbins -All critics gave particular attention to the exceptional performance by Noah Robbins. Spontaneous and truthful, Noah Robbins performance has earned those rare kinds of positive notices that come only once in a decade or so. A star-making performance of the rarest kind.
- Cromerfied Simon - Critics also were consistent in recognizing the unique nature of director David Cromer. Though the tone of Neil Simon comedies are often dictated by a desire to get laughs, Cromer has augmented the one-liners with an added dimension of reality. The humor is not muted in the production, but it is also not in the spotlight. Cromer has made a label for himself dusting off American classics and unearthing a particular classics authentic core. Critics loved this Cromerfied version of Simon’s comedy.
- All In The Family - The theme of family runs through Brighton Beach Memoirs, and most critics felt that dimension was solid in this production. However, a few critics felt that some performances lacked an authenticity of ethnicity that would have made the production more effective.
Should You See Brighton Beach Memoirs On Broadway?
Yes, especially if you like Neil Simon, comedy, family, Noah Robbins, Depression Era stories, jokes, star-making performances, Brighton Beach, coming-of-age stories, families, baseball, squabbles, dinners, one-liners, David Cromer, realism, nostalgia, and positively reviewed productions.
Opening Night Broadway Reviews of Brighton Beach Memoirs
As Eugene observes, love and loathing are inextricably linked in family relationships. If that paradox feels only fitfully real in this production, it achieves affectingly vital life whenever the squabbling, interdependent Jerome boys take to their room. -Ben Brantley, New York Times





BROADWAY MAGAZINE – Nothing to be done. The final play of the brilliant Broadway season of 2008-2009 opened last night, and today we offer our review matrix for Waiting For Godot, starring Nathan Lane and Bill Irwin. The praise for this production is nearly unanimous, with exceptional notices for stars Nathan Lane, Bill Irwin, John Glover, and John Goodman. Critics are in agreement that this production succeeds in capturing Beckett’s comic spirit, without sacrificing the haunting tone of the play. With strong reviews coming on the eve of the Tony Award nominations, look for Waiting For Godot to be one of the biggest hits on Broadway this Spring. Excerpts from reviews below:










